ack before Mirrodin Besieged previews, the five remaining Great Designer Search 2 finalists received feedback from the judges on their Challenge #3 submissions. One of them was cut from contention, and the remaining four were given the fifth Design Challenge—the final Challenge before the cut to Top 3.
Here's that Design Challenge again:
There are many ways for players to experience your set for the first time. One way is by opening a booster pack. Design Challenge #4 let you create the best experience for that entry. Today, we're going to be allowing you to tailor a different introduction. The goal for Design Challenge #5 will be to make an intro deck for your set.
Here's what's going to be asked of you:
- The deck must be exactly 60 cards.
- The deck must have exactly twelve uncommons, one rare, and one foil rare (visible through the packaging).
- The foil rare needs to be a splashy card that the players will want to play in the deck. Players who use intro decks want the shiny card in it to be good so we make sure to meet their expectations.
- You may have any number of lands and common cards to fill in the remaining 46 slots.
- You must have between 20 and 24 unique cards not counting basic land.
- You may have up to five cards from Magic 2011 (note that is five total; two copies of the same card count against that total).
- The deck should feature one of the set's themes.
- The deck needs to be fun to play. (We will play them. I urge you to as well.)
- Unless your theme strongly dictates otherwise, make the deck two colors.
- Don't include more than one new mechanic in your deck.
- There are no requirements for how many cards have to be yours or have to be someone else's.
- You may use cards that have been submitted before.
- You must provide a name for your deck. No logline is required. Please spend some time on this, as the deck name is an important element to setting the tone of your deck and set.
Here is what you will be judged on:
The quality of your deck: You are creating an intro deck. It needs to feel like one. You must follow all the guidelines above.
The quality of your cards: Not only must the deck be solid but also the individual designs of your cards. We will examine them both individually and in the context of your set.
The window into your world: Just as the booster pack was showing off your set, so too is the intro deck. You need to show off your world in the best way you can.
Improvement of your set: We've given you a lot of notes. We want to see this submission demonstrate that you were able to do what we asked. We understand that the restrictions of this Design Challenge will not allow you to show us everything, but we urge you to make a deck choice that allows us to see you've adopted some of the changes we've suggested.
Click on the names below to read the designers' booster pack submissions, and come back next week to read the judges' responses, see who gets cut, and find out the next Design Challenge!
Contestants' responses appear as submitted.